Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong

Well, at least we decided, right?  Hooray, we’re Deciders! We’ve been debating the viaduct so long that deciding has become a glorious end in itself.  Wretched.

What strikes me is how subdued the surface-option cartel has been about this so far.  Where’s the WTF?  Hey there Sightline, Worldchanging, Futurewise, Cascade Land Conservancy, Transportation Choices Coalition,  Seattle Great Cities Initiative, Sustainable Seattle, Allied Arts, and so on, are y’all going to make some noise?  Tell us Quality Growth Alliance, does the tunnel qualify as quality growth?  And hello UW Department of Urban Design and Planning, anybody home?  Might this be an opportunity to focus your awesome analytical resources on something a little more pressing than another publication in an obscure academic journal?

And isn’t anyone the the least bit peeved about how the painstaking work of the viaduct stakeholders committee was completely blown off?  And is it not troublingly bizarre, even if you support the tunnel, that the deep-bore solution was never seriously considered before now?

Ground control to Seattle:  The tunnel is stupid.  As some guy recently said, “the world has changed and we must change with it.”  The tunnel is a solution that is stunningly out of touch with future reality.  The tunnel will not age well at all.

Carry Moon and Mike Obrien’s recent PI op-ed goes a long way toward explaining why:

“Reorienting priorities around transit, compact growth, street connectivity, and providing people real alternatives to driving works for urban mobility, freight mobility and economic development. Spending $2 billion or more on tailpipe capacity with deep-bore tunnel — the most expensive option — is not a step toward a better future.”

Another piece of the equation is well-addressed in this Seattle Transit Blog post on how the tunnel would encourage sprawl and make transit less viable:

“Paradoxically, the Viaduct is actually bad for mobility. Because it allows people to entirely bypass downtown, it encourages spread out development…   This has always been the problem with highways – they break down the efficient hub and spoke structure of human settlement.”

And Sightline has been questioning the sanity of a high cost of a viaduct replacement since the Nisqually Quake (see this STB post for current cost analysis).  Of the $2.8 billion that the State has committed (not including the several billion more the tunnel will likely cost) Sightline noted:

“Calculate it per peak hour round trip—the only time when the street grid is currently full to capacity—and you’re talking ~$500,000 in taxpayer spending to support each round trip driver.”


Allow me to repackage the big picture reasons:

Climate Change:  The planet’s climate is headed off a cliff.  Those who have been right about climate change from the start are now advising that the IPCC’s target of 450 ppm CO2 is insufficient, and that we will need to stabilize at 350 ppm to avert climate catastrophe.  In the Puget Sound region, transportation accounts for nearly half of all greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.  And the State of Washington recently passed a law mandating a 50% reduction in vehicle miles traveled (VMT) by 2050.  Spending billions a tunnel that will increase GHG emissions from cars is not only a violation of State law: it is suicidal.

Energy:  We are almost certainly within a few years of peak oil, if we haven’t passed it already, while at the same time, demand for oil is spiking in developing countries with huge populations.  The era of cheap fuel for cars is ending.  This means that in the future we will drive less, and we will need more efficient alternatives, namely, transit.  As noted above, a downtown bypass like the tunnel would muck up the efficient hub and spoke urban layout that makes transit most efficient.  A good example of this New York City, where per capita energy use is lowest of all U.S. cities, primarily because so many people use transit.

Some believe that electric cars will arrive just in time to enable zero change in the way we get around.  I’m not so optimistic.  The electricity has to come from somewhere, and we’re talking about a huge amount of energy.  The rising cost of fossil fuels, restrictions on GHG emissions, and population growth will all be putting the squeeze on the U.S. electrical grid.  There are alternative sources like solar and wind, but as our supply of cheap fossil fuels dwindles, we will likely find ourselves scrambling for every possible source of electricity just to maintain existing output.  And here’s another gotcha: a conversion to electric cars would significantly increase water consumption (via The Oil Drum). So yes, we will have electric cars, but we will travel far fewer miles in them.

Economics:  It would be peachy if we had the excess wealth to build the tunnel and then just write it off if it turns out we don’t need or want it.  But we don’t have that luxury.  The U.S. federal deficit is the largest ever this year, and is expected to double next year.  Washington State has a $6 billion budget hole.  The $2.8 billion that the State has set aside for viaduct replacement is often discussed as if it’s a gift from the Gods that must be used for that purpose alone or else it will go up in smoke.  How asinine.  And same goes for the any billions we may get from the feds — it’s not free money.  There is an almost endless list of ways we could spend our money that would be more wise than buying a new tunnel.

The economy will rebound.  But unless we find an energy source as cheap, storable, and plentiful as fossil fuels were during the 20th century, it is delusional to believe that we can slip right back into economic business-as-usual for any significant length of time.  Energy is the elemental economic engine that delivers a high standard of living.  We are going to have to do more with less, and part of that equation will undoubtedly be a more localized way of life.  In other words, less driving around.  As in, a world in which multi-billion-dollar tunnels for cars start to look very, very dumb.

But here’s the thing: it’s not all bad.  Wouldn’t people would be better off spending less time in cars?  Wouldn’t communities be stronger if people lived more locally?  Our oil binge of the past century created wonders, but as with any binge, the downside is not fully appreciated until the hangover.  The party has been fun, but in all our excitement we’ve forgotten much about how to best nurture our human souls.  Time to take the keys away from the guy who’s stumbling toward the tunnel boring machine.

69 Responses to “Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong”

  1. Brazilian football

    Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings Black Varsity Red White Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings Black White Red Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings Championship Pack Phoenix Suns Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings Championship Pack Supersonics Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings GS – White White – Pale Blue Air Jordan 6 (Six) Rings Olympic

  2. Is This Thing On? | citytank

    […] enough? Not local enough? Would it help if I wrote something frothing at the mouth about the deep-bore tunnel? Do I need to stir things up with a self-righteous cycling […]

  3. Still Not Digging The Tunnel | citytank

    […] 01.23.09: Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong […]

  4. blue licenses holding llc

    blue licenses holding llc…

    […]Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong | hugeasscity[…]…

  5. hot deal

    hot deal…

    […]Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong | hugeasscity[…]…

  6. Alaska Renters Insurance

    Alaska Renters Insurance…

    […]Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong | hugeasscity[…]…

  7. The Other End of I-90: Same Old Same Old Parking Story | citytank

    […] a City where the vast majority of public transportation dollars are still spent of car infrastructure, such a claim is laughable, not to mention a straw man insult to those who hope to rebalance a […]

  8. www.loftbedsgiant.com


    Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong | hugeasscity…

  9. Sports Direct Free Delivery Code August 2011

    Sports Direct Free Delivery Code August 2011…

    Why The Tunnel Is So Wrong | hugeasscity…

  10. ubobet

    Ubobet is an internationally trusted gambling dealer back 2001 until now.
    By holding certified entrance for online gambling sites that
    pay for various types of betting games. Games clear affix Sportsbook, living Casino and Cockfight.
    Ubobet has reached the entire world gambling market including the Indonesian market.

    At present, all morning there are more than 100
    thousand players who entrust their bets in the city
    of Ubobet.

    Ubobet List Site

    To register an account, players cannot realize it directly on the Ubobet site.

    In new words, prospective players must register through the certified agent site for Ubobet listings such as
    Pandora188. By using Pandora188 ID the artist can bet on this city.
    How to register is quite easy, just by filling out the registration form
    correctly. After that create a layer of at least 25 thousand,
    after that the performer can bet on Ubobet.
    every performer who joins as a fanatic at Pandora188 is
    entitled to a freebet supplementary and afterward a daily growth other without exception.

    Ubobet Login

    After registering, players can log in upon Ubobet in two ways.
    The first is through ascribed partners who have collaborations such as Pandora188.
    Because the two sites have already formed a partnership,
    which means that betting on the Pandora188 site is the similar as betting upon Ubobet directly.
    Or by the second artifice you can directly log in to the Ubobet site if you already have an account.

    How to log in Ubobet is quite easy, just enter your ID & password correctly.

  11. Mabosway

    As an online gambling player, it is important
    to know what sites are good to visit and can be used as a place to proceed online gambling.
    carelessly choosing a site is tantamount to wasting capital for free.
    Not without help you will lose but also waste period and opportunity to succeed in this business.

    Not a few people make mistakes behind this until they finally drop into the abyss of bankruptcy
    / crush because they can’t win even in every game they do.

    Unfortunately, most people who experience this blame the
    game otherwise of introspecting upon what they have done.

    In essence, if you sham gambling absentmindedly and without preparation,
    like any other concern in the world, of course, you
    will end taking place in failure. Therefore, we want to come up with the
    money for recommendations for the best online gambling sites
    that you can visit and become followers playing online gambling to reach
    finishing in this industry.

    The herald of the site is Mabosway, a site that provides various types
    of unmovable and best-in-class online gambling games.

    upon the Mabosway site you can choose various types of games
    ranging from popular gambling games such as online poker, online casino gambling following various variants,
    as well as sports gambling games that are popular taking into account people in Indonesia.

    There are many more important features that the Mabosway site has, however, there are several important
    features that you habit to know that create Mabosway the best site and
    many online gambling players trust in Indonesia.

  12. mahaslot.wordpress.com

    There are in view of that many well-liked online slot games
    that you can find upon the internet. all of them provide
    re the thesame objection and of course the abundant give support to that you can gruffly
    acquire overnight. Getting rich in a brusque become old is now no longer just a desire because it is reachable to do.

    One of the online gambling that you should attempt to enjoy is called online slots.
    This game has been in relation to for hundreds of years
    and is nevertheless popular today. You could say slot gambling games
    are a type of gambling that has evolved fittingly
    rapidly, starting from the shape, appearance, to the game format.
    No gambling game can be as radical as the newest online slots.

    For those of you who are just starting to examine the online gambling business, here we will allocation basic tips and actions for talent in online slot gambling
    games. These tips will not urge on you keep winning in every game
    but will create your chances of winning augmented and cut the
    number of losses you will encounter.

  13. Gena

    Ion Casino

    Ion casino is a trusted and best on-line casino site from 2010 that has offered millions of gamers in Asia.
    Ion casino or also called Ionclub is the particular
    top ranking option site because it provides the greatest experience for internet
    gambling players in Indonesia. With an official license to
    run, this provider assures that players help to make bets without
    danger, credibility and may be depended on.

  14. sbobet.media

    Online gambling is no longer just a game that is over and done with to
    occupy spare time, now many people have made online gambling a profession that generates a lot of money, and this is
    in point of fact a reality. There is already a lot of
    evidence that shows that online gambling games have indeed been transformed
    into a no question profitable business.

    Since changing its form to online gambling, this game is increasingly
    admission to all circles. Where back online gambling
    was isolated approachable to upper class people, now everyone can experience and get
    the thesame opportunity. in the same way as else can you locate a thing that is profitable but furthermore
    fun to do.

    The uniqueness of the online gambling industry in Indonesia is that Indonesians cannot register
    directly to online gambling sites that have enough money
    gambling games because they are blocked by Indonesian performance which prohibits
    gambling. Therefore, a connecting portal is needed that can be a bridge amongst online
    gambling fans and online gambling game providers.

    Therefore, the presence of online gambling agents is agreed important in Indonesia.
    The show of online gambling agents is to provide domestic potential players
    when entry to games provided by online gambling sites by
    providing recommendation to make an official account that can be
    used to log into the game.

    One of the endorsed online gambling agent sites
    that manage to pay for these facilities is Sbobet.media.
    Sbobet.media has been on previously 2017 and has become a colleague for millions of online gambling players in Indonesia to the best and most trusted online gambling game.
    For those of you who want to register, you unaided habit to
    visit the site and register online.

  15. judi casino

    Sbobet Casino is a type of online casino gambling game that has mushroomed in Indonesia.
    Players no lengthier need to maneuver from their benches to play
    casino gambling, because now with the advancement in technology the gambling
    industry has now entered a new phase known as online gambling.
    Present Sbobet provider as the best wagering
    promoter in Asia with the web betting method certainly provides more advantages because it is readily available to you wherever and whenever you need it.

  16. situs depoxito

    Depoxito is the best online gambling site in Indonesia, like
    Depoxito you will mood the sensation of playing supplementary
    and advanced online gambling. We always innovate
    as a result that all our members can vibes a sensation behind playing
    at a real casino. Depoxito manage to pay for you the best rouse casino feelings you
    can get taking into consideration every the lovely and sexy dealers,
    or grand vip saloon private room for our VIP fanatic where you can bill one on one subsequently our special
    Dealer all just for yourself.
    Luxurious site and VIP class advance for you, a avant-garde and easy-to-use site,
    friendly and always friendly Customer serve to help
    you. Depoxito is the right another for those of
    you who desire to take steps online gambling without excruciating that your winnings will not be paid, Depoxito guarantees that every bet you area and win is true and
    will be paid without incurring any unwritten deductions.

    Depoxito as a site that is a co-conspirator of
    international big bookmakers entirely will not disappoint you
    as a loyal enthusiast of the Depoxito site and will continue to plan new updates and
    amend our security system therefore that it can prevent our loyal members
    from the threat of personal data leakage, scam or fraud.

    Depoxito is also a trusted online gambling dealer that
    provides the most pure gambling games in Indonesia, such as sportsbook, slot games, breathing casino, lottery and online poker that you can discharge
    duty when just 1 Account.
    In complement to the given VIP abet game on our site, we will pamper you our
    faithful members because you don’t obsession a lot of IDs
    to perform rotate gambling games. As a gambling
    site accredited by PAGCOR (Philippines Amusement and Gaming Corporation) Depoxito is as
    a consequence one of the number one gambling sites
    in Indonesia and has a good reputation from
    all online gambling players in Indonesia.
    As we have said, we have a customer sustain that is always on standby to help every your needs though
    playing on our site, including for withdrawals and deposits that lonesome acknowledge less than 3 minutes,
    in view of that we can be the best for devotee promote in addition to
    our customer help will standby 24 hour a daylight and 7 days a week to minister to our advocate and VIPs.

    And the most special from our site compared to
    new sites is the supplementary that we have the funds for to our faithful members
    who continue to performance on our site will get the best promos and bonuses that
    we will have enough money you, we always follow the broadcast and
    trends that are viral now hence the promos that we make are
    of course no less than any site. For VIP members we
    always provide special promos that are not written suitably that our
    members continue to behave on our site depoxito.

  17. mabosbola.net

    Mabosbola is an online gambling site that provides the most popular soccer gambling
    and casino online games which have been set up since 2013. Since this
    site appeared and provides gambling services to all customers in Philippines,
    Mabosbola has dared to provide deal security to all their official members up to a nominal vast amounts of rupiah.

    This specific is the reason many world-class betting game providers at the degree of Sbobet and
    Maxbet want to work with Mabosbola. So far, there have been many gambling,
    soccer wagering and online on line casino game providers that have collaborated with Mabosbet, including Sbobet, Nova88, Ion, and WM Casino.

    On our official site, you can enjoy a number
    of00 the best and many popular games, beginning from soccer gambling video games such as Oriental Handicap,
    1X2, or total score or challenging casino wagering games such as roulette,
    blackjack, sicbo and so on. You can get this just by registering to turn into
    a associate on the official online gambling site Mabosbola.

    How to Sign up for a web based Betting Account
    Once we explained earlier, for anyone who want to enjoy the best online games
    in Indonesia, we recommend that you register as an official member on the
    online gambling site Mabosbola. Besides being
    easy, you also only need a few minutes to sign-up.

  18. promosbobet.Com

    enjoyable and thank you for visiting online casino agents for Indonesia.

    Here we are here to pay for admission for fans of sbobet casino who
    desire to associate the international agent site Promosbobet.

    The products offered are certainly diverse and are enormously the best
    choice. Derived from providers that have credibility and have been proven to have the best predicate in serving their customers.

    Providers considering Sbobet, Maxbet and many more.

    As the best online casino and soccer gambling site in Indonesia.
    We give maximum serve subsequent to customer
    preserve that works online 24 full hours every day.
    correspondingly members can statute whenever and wherever without fearing to
    aim the possibility of difficulties or confusion.

  19. link alternatif

    Option Link l69
    L69 is one of the official sites that supply the newest alternative link
    trustworthy online betting sites. L69 provides more than just one alternative link from each betting site, and we
    all here have become the most comprehensive alternative link suppliers
    and the L69 internet site has a responsive display that makes it easy that you should access
    our site from the display of your gadget or laptop.
    Plus what you should know is that we here just
    have one official link, l69. me personally and if there usually are other websites that supply information or call
    the website is not our own official site.
    Ball gambling and casino gambling usually are types of games that
    are extremely popular with the men and women regarding Indonesia.
    Why l69? Because we’ve been here for more than five years and possess become the
    trust of the folks of Philippines as a location to enjoy soccer gambling
    and in addition on-line casino gambling. Itself in addition has obtained a license through the Asian and Western governments last
    season to become an online gambling gambling provider
    site in Parts of asia and Europe. By providing lots of different types of gambling
    bets that may be played upon one ID, it makes the particular
    members feel happy playing in your bookie.
    Advantages of Alternative Links l69
    Nevertheless regrettably lately there usually are many members who experience problems
    and problems when entering into their Sbobet game for the reason that Sbobet web site is normally blocked and lots of older sites have been clogged by the Indonesian government and
    never a few usually are also impacted with what is
    called the Newsletter Task. The Indonesian government recently is struggling to get rid of links or paths to
    get into sites that smell associated with pornography, gambling and
    right now there are a number of other content that will is
    deemed inappropriate.

Leave a Reply